Wolf row photographer stripped of award

By Vicky Shaw, Press Association

A stunning image capturing a wolf leaping over a gate has been stripped of first place in the Wildlife Photographer of the Year competition after judges found the animal was likely to be a "model".

The winning entry, by photographer Jose Luis Rodriguez, beat thousands of entries to scoop the prize in October last year, receiving praise for its "fairytale" quality.

But an investigation was launched after suspicions were raised that the picture might breach competition rules.

Rule 10 says that photographs of animal models may not be entered into the competition and that images will be disqualified if they are entered in breach.

A statement from competition organisers said Mr Rodriguez strongly denies that the wolf is a model.

Owned by the Natural History Museum and BBC Wildlife Magazine, the long-running contest is billed as an international showcase for the best nature photography.

Louise Emerson, from the Wildlife Photographer of the Year competition office, said today: "It saddens us to confirm that after a careful and thorough investigation into the image, the storybook wolf, the co-owners of the Wildlife Photographer of the Year competition, the Natural History Museum and BBC Wildlife Magazine have disqualified the winning entry of the photographer Jose Luis Rodriguez.

"The judging panel was reconvened and concluded that it was likely that the wolf featured in the image was an animal model that can be hired for photographic purposes and, as a result, that the image had been entered in breach of Rule 10 of the Competition.

"The judging panel looked at a range of evidence and took specialist advice from panel judges who have extensive experience of photographing wildlife including wolves.

"They also considered the responses to specific questions put to the photographer Jose Luis Rodriguez."

The £10,000 prize money was never awarded to Mr Rodriguez, but he did receive a £500 category winner's cheque, which organisers said they had agreed he could retain in lieu of royalty payments.

They said first place would not be re-awarded as judging is always done "blind" so that an objective choice can be made about the winner.

Ms Emerson continued: "Wildlife Photographer of the Year is the world's most prestigious photography competition of its kind.

"Any transgression of the competition rules is taken very seriously and if entries are suspected of breaching the rules they are disqualified.

"Jose Luis Rodriguez's image will be removed from the exhibition and tour.

"Mr Rodriguez strongly denies that the wolf in the image is a model wolf."

I really don't give an owls hoot about wildlife photography, but found this quite interesting, and a little funny.

Lets say the Wolf is a model, or what is more likely an image of a wolf taken from somewhere else. Who cares. I am guessing the judges are just embarrassed they didn't realize the image has fishy written all over it. I think an image of a Werewolf would of been much more convincing and fun..

Hey Roddy, if you used a telephoto (or at least make it look that way) you may have stood a chance. No one gets that close to a Wolf in the wild. I could go on and say the Wolf is not positioned far enough over the fence, or animals jumping like that show up all kinds of muscle and movement dont looked stuffed, or why is a lone wolf jumping a flipping fence. But I wont.

I guess the real problem it how do you prove it..

1 comment:

Andrew Bruce said...

I remember saying to a few people that I wished the wolf was a little bit overexposed or there was some kind of flaw, as it would have just made it that little bit more real... funny now this has surfaced...
it's one exceptionally striking image whatever..